In chapter two on page 29 Woodford makes the following statement:
"An overemphasis on on intellecualism, skill, or talent may contribute to elitism and the political and cultural mainstrems, while an overemphasis on emotion, spectacle, ritual or musical commodification may also contribute to the undetermining of democratic culture by failing to adequately prepare children to participate in public musical life. Either approach may contribute to the disfranchisment of children when music teachers ought to be providing more musical leadership with repsect to increasing the breath, depth and vitaltiy of students' musical experiences so that they can contribute to democratization of musical culture."
My question is that how do you find a middle? Outside of the music classroom students are exposed to the media frenzy of music, as Woodward loosely describes it the Disney version, but in the classroom music educators are considered to be old-fashioned, putting too much emphasis on skill and talent to promote "elitism". I strongly believe that music is for everyone, regardless of natural born ability, but I also think that students need to have the opportunity to build stronger musical skills than they have been given in the past. Where do we find the line between pop culture and western cannon then if both are important in their own right?
Labels: Partner questions II
1 Comments:
I believe that it is each teacher’s responsibility to find the middle ground between popular music and Western cannon. It is important to realize the connections that can be made between the two, how popular music can still relate to Western Cannon, and how it was derived. I think that if teachers can put the learning into an interesting, engaging format that students would be more interested as well as learn more about music as a whole. This way, students will be learning about music they don’t know from the music they have known all their lives.
To develop skills, teachers must reinforce the learning through kinesthetic activities. This way if a student is learning about the blues, he/she can hear it, talk about it, know its history, AND be able to play it. These are the skills that even a student with out natural abilities would benefit from. To sum up what I am saying, I feel that there is not a line between popular music and Western Cannon to be drawn, but rather a pool full of all music that can be drawn from.
Post a Comment
<< Home